Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Maria (Linnesby essays)'s avatar

I’m in the minority here, I see, but I like the added line. Not so much for the imagery, but for what the sounds add to the whole — the near-rhyme of “haze” and “fad-,” and the “far” picked up again first in “hor—“ and then a different way in “fad-“ again. And then “away” closing out with more near rhyme. And more… It all adds a sensibility of artfulness that isn’t there in the first version, and that for me at least feels like a gift in this case.

Thank you for these!

.

Expand full comment
Isaac Kolding's avatar

The debate about the Farm Picture aside, that first poem is stunning. I can only hope that my old age is like that--enlarging and spreading, not pinching and shrinking. I've spent a lot of time with Whitman, but not enough time with these short poems; I'll have to find an anthology of them. Any suggestions?

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts